During prohibition times in America, illegal speakeasies popped up along the shores, perfect for smuggling alcohol into the country. One of them was the Moss Beach Distillery in California, and the restaurant as well as the beach is said to be haunted by The Lady in Blue.
Perched high on a wind-battered cliff along California’s rugged San Mateo Coast, overlooking the restless Pacific, the Moss Beach Distillery by a secluded beach stands as one of the West Coast’s most charming — and most haunted — landmarks.
Read More: Check out all ghost stories from the USA
Since its inception in 1927, during the heady, illicit days of Prohibition, the Distillery has weathered decades of history, scandal, and ghost stories 20 miles south of San Francisco. But none are as enduring, or as chilling, as the legend of The Lady in Blue.
A Speakeasy by the Sea
The Moss Beach Distillery in San Mateo County was born as Frank’s Place by Frank Torres, an exclusive speakeasy frequented by silent film stars, bootleggers, and thrill-seekers eager to escape the suffocating moral codes of the day and it was never raided. Mystery writer Dashiell Hammett frequented the place and used it as a setting for one of his detective stories.
Its hidden passageways, secret compartments for smuggled Canadian whiskey, and cliffside location made it the perfect den for mischief, music — and, if whispers are true, murder.
Among the regular guests was a striking young woman known only as Mary Anne or Morley, sometimes known as Cateye by different psychics.Mostly she is just referred to as The Lady in Blue as she was known to always wear a blue dress. Mary was a married woman who, despite the risk, became entangled in a passionate and ultimately tragic affair with John Contina, the establishment’s charismatic piano player, according to some.
A Love Story Drenched in Blood
The lovers’ meetings were clandestine, their affections fueled by the risk and thrill of forbidden romance. But fate — or perhaps jealousy — intervened one fog-laden night. According to the most persistent version of the tale, as Mary and John strolled hand in hand along the desolate beach, they were ambushed by a shadowy figure. Mary was brutally attacked and killed. Though John initially survived, his battered body was later found washed ashore, lifeless and broken.
Other versions suggest different outcomes — a car crash, a lover’s quarrel, or the tragic suicide of another scorned mistress, Anna Philbrick, who allegedly hurled herself from the cliffs upon learning of John’s betrayal. In still other versions, she is a lovesick woman who throws herself into the sea.
Yet no matter which telling you choose, one element remains constant: Mary’s spirit never left Moss Beach.
The Lady in Blue’s Restless Haunting
For nearly a century, patrons and employees alike have claimed unsettling encounters with a female apparition clad in flowing blue. She appears on foggy nights, drifting through the restaurant, brushing cold fingers against the living, or vanishing into thin air before startled eyes.
Visitors have reported whispers with no source, objects moving on their own, and inexplicable technical disturbances like the phone calling from no one. Perhaps the most infamous incident occurred when, without warning, the restaurant’s computer system inexplicably reset — changing every date in the system to 1927, the year the Distillery first opened its doors. Technicians could find no reason for the glitch, and the anomaly has since become a part of The Lady in Blue’s eerie legacy.
Staff members working late have heard the piano play itself, and some refuse to close alone. One employee swears she saw a woman in blue watching from a corner of the empty dining room, only to vanish when approached. Apparently in the 70s, a worker remodeling the restaurant saw her and went back to southern California, too scared to go back and finish the job. Guests have even claimed to see a blue-clad figure staring longingly out toward the cliffs, as though waiting for a lover who never returned.
Also by the water there has been reported about spirit activity. Kids playing on the sandy beach have claimed that some woman in a blue dress came warning them about playing so close to the waters right before a sudden high tide rushed into the shore.
Fact, Folklore, and Foggy Nights
Though no official records confirm the names of Mary, John Contina, or Anna Philbrick, the persistent nature of The Lady in Blue legend suggests a powerful cultural memory — one perhaps born from Moss Beach’s turbulent Prohibition past and its reputation for danger and romance on the edge of the world.
Although today there is a strong figure in the area, there is little evidence of the story before the 1980s. This is when Mike and Shirley Sarno took over the restaurant and gave an interview about the legend of The Lady in Blue in the San Francisco Examiner.
Their names, Mary or Mary Morley, come from a series of scenes done by Sylvia Browne in April 1992. According to this seance, a fire broke out just a few days after her ghost had warned the staff.
Whether Mary was a wronged wife, a doomed lover, or simply a figment of California’s colorful lore, her ghost seems determined to linger, forever entwined with the crashing surf and shifting sands of Moss Beach.
If you dare to visit, sip a drink, listen for the whispers, and cast your gaze toward the cliffs at twilight. You might just catch a glimpse of The Lady in Blue, forever walking the shore between the worlds of the living and the dead.
Newest Posts
- The Basilisk of Basel: The Beast Beneath GerberbergleinOnce upon a time there used to live a Basilisk in a cave underneath where the Tanner’s Fountain (Gerberberglein) is today. Said to kill with its poisonous breath even, it has become the very symbol of Basel today.
- The Bailiff of Brunegg: A Ghostly Hunt Through Swiss Snow and SinAfter taking his regime of terror too far on a stormy winter night, the Bailiff of Brunegg committed a sin so huge on a hunt that would send him into a haunted afterlife.
- Free Horror Short Stories Perfect for Christmas and Dark Winter EveningsWhy did we stop telling ghost stories for Christmas? In the olden days, it used to be a tradition to gather around and tell each other ghost stories in Victorian England. Often set in cold and dark castles or somewhere far remote in the cold icy night. Here are some perfect short stories you can read for free, perfect for Christmas time.
- Dark Christmas Legends and Traditions from Around the WorldHow about having a look about the darker things that Christmas has to offer. It’s not all just ugly sweaters and sweet eggnog. Here are some of the Dark Christmas Legends from around the world, bringing the spooky tales and traditions we are missing during yule times.
- The Portent of the Shadow by E. NesbitThe Portent of the Shadow or just The Shadow is set during a Christmas gathering of friends, one guest tells of a terrifying, supernatural encounter involving an otherworldly shadow that leads to madness and death. Classic Edwardian Christmas ghostliness.
- The White Lady of Rouelbeau Castle Ruins Appearing for ChristmasIn the ruins of the former castle of Rouelbeau in Switzerland, the ghost of a Lady in White is said to appear during Christmas times. As one of the Weiße Frau from Germanic folklore, she is believed to have been the mistress of the castle until she was cast away for not bearing a son.
- The Story of a Disappearance and an Appearance by M.R JamesOne of James’s lesser-known but fascinating tales — set at Christmas, it’s presented as a series of letters about a disturbing Punch and Judy show, a mysterious disappearance, and a spectral visitation on Christmas Eve. It first appeared in print in the June 4, 1913 issue of the magazine Cambridge Review. It was published again in 1919 as part of the anthology A Thin Ghost and Others.
- The Ghost Soldiers of Rapperswil Ringing the Bell of St. JohnIn the middle of the night, it was said that the bells of St. John Church in Rapperswil, Switzerland started to toll. When the churchwarden went to investigate, it was said that he saw the headless ghosts of the fallen soldiers from the Battle of Näfels holding midnight mass.
- The Night of Christmas Eve by Nikolai GogolSet in snowy Ukraine on Christmas Eve, this folkloric tale follows a trickster devil who wreaks havoc in a village while a young man seeks to win his beloved’s heart under supernatural influence.
- Ghosts of the Holy Season: The Christmas Hauntings of BernEach December, when the nights grow long and the spirit of Christmas fills the air, Bern’s holiday phantoms awaken. These tales from lore and legends, remind us that even amidst celebration, the spirits of bygone eras linger.
- Jerry Bundler by W. W. JacobsAt a cozy inn on Christmas Eve, guests trade spooky stories—until a real, bloodstained intruder named “Jerry Bundler” appears, turning festive warmth into true fright.
- The Haunted House of Ludington: A Christmas Ghost StoryAll year round, the residents of the House in Ludington, seem to be plagued by the ghost waking them up from their sleep and watching them from the rocking chair. Around Christmas time, the ghost is said to be the one placing the Christmas Angel on the Christmas Tree.
References:
History + Ghost – Moss Beach Distillery
She’s the Bay Area’s most famous ghost. But her origin story is suspect.
The Lady in Blue: Ghost on the Coast
Moss Beach Distillery – Wikipedia
Moss Beach Distillery Is a California Bar with a Killer View—and Clientele
