Who is haunting Higbee Beach in Jersey Shore? Is it because of the disturbed Higbee Grave, perhaps the drowned victims of a shipwreck?
The Jersey Shore, with its cheerful boardwalks, sun-drenched beaches, and echoing call of seagulls, hides its darker side well. Beneath the bright veneer of seaside towns and saltwater taffy, ancient whispers cling to the sands, refusing to be silenced by time or tide. Nowhere is this more evident than at Higbee Beach in Cape May, New Jersey—a wild stretch of shore where ghost stories gather like mist on the water. And among these, one figure stands out: the Man in Tatters.
A Beach with a History Written in Shadows
Long before Higbee Beach became a sanctuary for birdwatchers and intrepid hikers, it was the home of Joseph and Thomas Higbee, two brothers who operated a hotel known as The Hermitage in the 1800s. This secluded, untamed beach at the southern tip of New Jersey was a world unto itself—remote, windswept, and shrouded in mystery. Following the death of the Higbee brothers in the 1870s, the property and surrounding land passed to their niece, Etta Gregory. But it was Thomas Higbee’s final wish that cemented his name to the land in a way no one expected.
Read More: Check out all ghost stories from USA
In accordance with his will, Thomas was buried on the very island he so loved in a grave lined with brick and flagstone. The grave was sealed with a large marble slab.
But already in 1937, his remains were unearthed and moved to Cold Spring Cemetery by Etta to be next to her, in an act many locals quietly believed to be a grave mistake. The hotel was demolished in 1940. As the legend goes, disturbing the dead rarely ends well, and Higbee Beach soon gained a new, unwelcome reputation.
The Ghostly Figure at Dusk
As daylight fades and the sun sinks beneath the Atlantic, a peculiar chill is said to settle over Higbee Beach. Visitors recount fleeting glimpses of a gaunt, pale man wandering the shoreline. Descriptions are remarkably consistent with an almost luminous gray light. This description was first found in a woman’s recounter of her experiences in the book: Cape May Ghost Stories from 1988.
His pants were too short and frayed at the cuffs, a sash tied at his waist instead of a belt, and a filthy, tattered T-shirt clinging to his spectral form. Sometimes he’s described with a long coat. His presence is often accompanied by a large, black dog, its eyes glinting unnaturally in the twilight, padding silently at his side.
Some say this ghost is Thomas Higbee himself, forever condemned to search for the grave he was cruelly torn from. Some say it’s his slave who is watching over his master’s grave in his afterlife. The connection between restless spirits and disturbed burial grounds runs deep in folklore, and this story is no exception. Locals claim that the man in tatters appears most often around dusk, when the boundary between worlds softens and the veil grows thin.
Shipwrecked Immigrants
There is not only the man in the tattered clothes that people claim is haunting the beach. There are also those who say that the ghosts haunting this place could be of a ship carrying immigrants to shore from Europe. Many died during the accident.
Some claim to have heard screaming coming from the water as they stroll along the beach. Could it be that the ghosts of the drowned are still lingering? Some also speculate that there could be soldiers that lost their lives during test bombing during world war two that are haunting the beach.
Higbee’s Ghost Dog
Adding to the ghostly tableau is the figure of the black dog—an omen of death and misfortune in countless cultures. In Cape May, the creature is sometimes called a hellhound, said to guard the beach’s hidden secrets: lost shipwreck victims, ancient pirate treasure, or the tormented soul of Higbee himself. The dog is always near the Man in Tatters, never leaving his side.
Eyewitnesses have reported watching the man and his hound dissolve into the mist as they approach, leaving no footprints in the damp sand.
Even today, long after The Hermitage crumbled and the Higbee family passed into obscurity, the ghost of the Man in Tatters persists. Higbee Beach Wildlife Management Area may draw birders and nature lovers by day, but as the sun dips low and the air turns heavy, seasoned locals quietly warn visitors not to linger too long after dusk.
Newest Posts
- Daníelspyttur and the Boy who Drowned and Haunts it
In a remote area in Iceland, the Daníelspyttur is named after a boy who once took off from work and drowned in the water. Ever since, people have thought it haunted as well as the surrounding area. - The Dream of the Basel Rhine Bridge about the Buried Treasure
A legend goes that a simple farmer from the Emmental in the Swizz alps had a dream about finding gold at the bridge in Basel. Visited by a ghostly shadow, he was guided around the country to find it. - The Haunting of Dalen Hotel and the English Lady of Room 17
In the deep fjords of Norway, the Dalen Hotel is one of the places said to be haunted by a guest who never really checked out. Who was the English Lady of Room 17? - Hvítárvellir-Skotta comes to Haunt a Family for over 120 Years
How long can a ghost linger? Some Icelandic ghost stories claim it is for 120 years. But if we are to believe the legend of Hvítárvellir-Skotta, she has been haunting a particular family for much longer. Perhaps even today? - The Haunting of the Antoniterkirche: Where the Monks Never Left
The transition from Catholicism to Protestantism sometimes got bloody. This was also the case in Bern where the Antonite monks of Antoniterkirche had been residing for centuries. Cast out, their former churches and chapels were left desecrated, but did they truly leave the city? - The Dying Screams of a Girl on Fire Haunting the Screaming Tunnel in Canada
Said to be haunted by the dying screams of a young girl who was set on fire and died, the Screaming Tunnel in Niagara Falls in Canada has become the site of some of the most eerily ghost legends said to linger within the dark. - The Restless Gatekeeper of the Rhine Gate in Basel
After the gatekeeper’s young daughter died in the Rhine, his only wish was to be buried next to her in the cemetery. As they all believed his own death was a suicide he was denied a burial in a consecrated ground. Now, he is forced to linger in the shadows, his only way to visit her grave. - The Haunting of Nes Church Ruins in Norway
The mysterious Nes Church Ruins in Norway has attracted ghost hunters and legends for centuries by now. But what is really lurking among the old stones after dark? - The Ghost of the Hay at Hvítárvellir on the White Floor
On the night before her wedding, a girl was tracked down by a ghost sent to kill her. Who was behind the haunting, and where did the ghost go after their encounter? - The Slave Trader of Ebenrain: A Tormented Spirit in the Shadows of Sissach
Meant to be a peaceful summer residence in Sissach, outside of Basel in Switzerland, the Ebenrain Castle turned into a haunted one after one of its former inhabitants is still haunting it. - The Eerie and Haunted History of Old City Hall in Toronto
Said to be haunted by numerous ghosts, the Old City Hall in Toronto, Canada is now known as one of the creepiest buildings in the city. From strange entities targeting judges’ robes in the stairs to the last executed prisoners in the country, the spirits of the building are said to linger. - The Ghostly Monk of Spittelsprung (Münsterberg) in Basel
Back at a time when the hills of Münsterberg were called Spittelsprung in the really old parts of Basel in Switzerland, it was also said a monk was haunting the streets. Gliding in and out of the houses frightening the children, he took no notice of the world of the living, always deep in his prayers. The question is, prayer for what?
References:
The Ghosts of Higbee Beach – High Tide
One thought on “The Restless Ghosts Roaming Higbee Beach at Cape May”