The Inn at Stonecliffe on Mackinac Island

On the summer vacation Mackinac Island, there are plenty of dark and haunted stories. At the Inn at Stonecliffe, there are rumors that the ghost of a little girl just wants to go home.

In the glistening waters of Lake Huron between Michigan’s Upper and Lower Peninsulas, Mackinac Island is a serene retreat known for its picturesque beauty, historic charm, and an eerie reputation for the supernatural. In fact, Mackinac Island was called the most haunted town in America in 2021, with many stories having been covered over the years. And with only a full time population of around 583 people, the ghosts perhaps even outnumber the living.

Read More: Check out all ghost stories from the USA

With no cars allowed and transportation limited to bicycles and horse-drawn carriages, the island offers a unique step back in time. Some come to enjoy the quiet seaside and enjoy the famous fudge. The island has become a perfect summer destination for Americans, but after the tourists leave in the fall, the fog from the Straits comes rolling in, and the leaves turn color, the ghost of the island remains to haunt it.

A Brief History of Mackinac Island

Mackinac Island’s history stretches back thousands of years, with indigenous peoples such as the Odawa, Ojibwe, and Huron considering it a sacred place long before European settlers arrived. The island’s name itself, derived from the Ojibwe word “Michilimackinac,” means “big turtle,” referring to the island’s shape when viewed from above.

Read more: Check out all ghost stories from Mackinac Island

The French established a fur trading post here in the 17th century, and the island later became a strategic military outpost during the Revolutionary War and the War of 1812. In the late 19th century, it became more of a summer colony and a tourist destination that it still is.

Free Mackinac Island Michigan photo and picture — **Mackinac Island:** Cars were banned at the end of the nineteenth century due to health and safety concerns for the island’s residents and horses, as local carriage drivers said it scared their horses. This, together with the old historic houses and lush nature makes you feel like stepping back in time and welcoming old ghosts to linger.

The Ghost Haunting The Inn at Stonecliffe

The Inn at Stonecliffe is an old establishment two miles from the downtown. It was built in 1904 by an industrialist named Michael Cudahy and is considered a luxury hotel. The hotel is both the central Mansion as well as the Summer House. Placed high on a bluff near the airport on the west side of the island it is a popular wedding destination, and retreat for those wanting something calm and away from the bustling city life.

Not much is known about the haunting at the Inn at Stonecliffe itself and the sources are few, except from all the confused and sometimes scared customers leaving reviews about seeing something that could have been paranormal.

One of the stories that have reached online is the alleged haunting of the ghost servant, still toiling away at the hotel and a little girl heard playing in the halls.

The Woman Haunting Brides at Inn at Stonecliffe

There also is a legend of a woman who was engaged to be married to a British soldier. When this was, if it was before the building that is now the Inn at Stonecliffe was built when the British had control over the fort, or after the building was built is unknown.

In any case it was said that he died before the wedding and she was inconsolable. Whatever happened to her after, the story doesn’t speak much of, but she returned to this popular wedding venue to haunt it after she died. She is said to wreak havoc on some of the wedding ceremonies performed at the Inn at Stonecliffe.

The Ghost of Frances Lacey of Dearborn and her Unsolved Murder

Another story tied to the property rather than the building itself is the unsolved murder said to haunt the island.

On a Sunday, July 24 in 1960, Frances Lacey of Dearborn, a rich widow went missing. She was staying at The Murray Hotel. Five days later, she was found murdered.

Her body was found on the Stone Cliff property, then owned by the Moral Re-Armament Organization who owned most of Mission Point. So not exactly connected to the Inn at Stonecliffe, but at the property. The organization owning the property at the time is probably also why her story often comes up with tales of Mission Point Resort. Although this particular resort is closer to Murray Hotel, it is from the other side of the island from where she was found.

It was said her body was found in the bushes close to what was called Devil’s Kitchen. That is a small cave on the island with local stories claiming that the Native Americans considered the cave to be a spiritual location inhabited by bad spirits. Allegedly, the spirits were cannibals who would capture and eat victims who ventured too close to the ill-omen location. How true this legend is though is unsure, or if it was something made up in the later years for tourism.

She had been strangled, but her murder went unsolved. After this, people have talked about experiencing her ghost haunting the premise as well. Both in the area where she was found as well as the hotel she went missing from known as The Murray Hotel.